Gear Review: Bandana vs Buff

Almost 10 years ago, I saw my first person wearing a buff:

His name was Rich. We were on the Tibetan Plateau, and, unlike me, Rich actually knew what the hell he was doing. I figured if I couldn’t actually know what the hell I was doing, looking like I knew what the hell I was doing was the next best thing. So, I set about acquiring a buff. As you might imagine, there aren’t a ton of outdoors stores on the middle of the Plateau, so I decided the next best thing was to tie a bandana around my neck:

DSC_0032.jpg

It wasn’t a good look.

In my desperate attempt to not look like an idiot, I had, in fact, managed to look like an idiot. A summers worth of practice only made things marginally better:

dsc_0029

Upon returning home I saw these pictures, attempted to score them from my memory, and gave up the bandana for a buff. If you’ve seen me hiking since then, I’ve been wearing one:

_DSC5241

But recently, when I was working on my book review of The Apache Wars I realized something: nearly every single person in every single picture was wearing a bandana. And they didn’t look as dumb as me.

mickey_free_e28093_apache_indian_scout

Mickey Free, for example, looks positively bad-ass in his bandana here. Though, if we’re being honest, that might be the giant rifle talking.

Padre, who is stubborn in all things including bandana selection (“They just don’t make bandanas like they used to”– an actual quote from Padre), consistently looks cool in his bandana.

_DSC9614

And these guys aren’t idiots. So I picked up the best bandana I could find (aSchnee’s Wild Rag) and I took it upon myself to revaluate.


COMFORT

_DSC6653

I have a confession to make. For years I’ve been telling every human being who will listen that the buff isn’t all that warm. I’ve been lying. While it doesn’t get killer hot, the buff is just a little too tight to breath comfortable for me. Better than a sunburn, sure, but still noticeably warmer than hiking with nothing around my neck.

Now take that with a grain of salt: I live in Arizona. In the summer, we hike in the mountains up north and it is just a little too warm to be comfortable. In the winter, we hike in the mountains closer to home, and it is still slightly too warm to be comfortable.

This is the main difference between the buff and the bandana. The bandanna can be tied lose enough that it still provides all the sun protection you need while still letting your neck breathe. What’s more the silk material breathes far better than the synthetic buffs I’ve tried.

_DSC7809


LOOKS

Quick question: while you wear your buff are you saving a yak trapped in prayer flags from the edge of a cliff?

SONY DSC

If the answer to that question was no, you don’t look cool in your buff.

_DSC6653

Unfortunately you probably won’t look cool in your bandana either. I believe the term “hiking ascot” has come up more than once.

_DSC7816


VERSATILITY

Of course, buff’s claim to fame is that it can be worn a billion different ways. For example, here I’ve got one on as a beanie under my beloved Tilly Hat.

_DSC9290

The bandana falls short here, but just barely– you can tie it all the ways you can a buff, but ultimately the long tails that let you tie it loose are always in the way a little bit.

_DSC1520

Addendum: 3 November 2016

I found another sweet use for the bandanna.

_DSC2865.jpg

_dsc2869

Try doing that with a buff.


A tangential story: after years of buying the next latest and greatest product to stay warm, I’ve found myself slowly gravitating back to wool.  Wool breathes well, doesn’t stink, regulates body temperature, and can even be used as a sleeping bag for your toddler in a pinch.

_DSC1460

Which leave me with a question: how far has a hundred years of materials innovation really gotten us? Well, unless you’re hiking 30 miles a day (weight/bulk really really matters) or taking on the dead of winter at high elevations (maximum warmth really really matters), not really a whole lot. Well put together wool can do basically everything all your fancy synthetics can, and in many cases do it better.

Which brings us back to the buff. A couple of months replacing my buff with a good (and that part is important) bandana has made me realize that the story is much the same. The bandana is more comfortable while doing its job just as well. Sure, you can’t wear it in quite as many ways, but when was the last time you as anything other than a headband or neck/face shield anyways?

Count me a convert.


Disclaimer: This post, and all posts on LesserPlaces, may contain affiliate links– links that allow me to receive a small kickback at no additional cost to you when you shop through them. This is how we keep the lights on. 



Don’t forget you can follow Lesser Places by email, or on Twitter, Tumblr, andInstagram using the menu at the top of the page. Or, you could click the links below to share with your friends directly. Or, copy and paste the URL someplace you think people will find it useful. Or, print the story, place it in a nice envelope, and send it to one of your friends. Basically we support any way you want to share.  No, we aren’t above begging.


39082_966963051231_919342_n

Max Wilson is a graduate student studying ecology at Arizona State University. He writes here at Lesser Places, occasionally for Backpacker.com, and even more occasionally for scientific journals. You can follow him on twitter @maxomillions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s